Serious neck injuries in U19 rugby union players: an audit of admissions to spinal injury units in Great Britain and Ireland
- 1Department of Orthopaedics, Perth Royal Infirmary, Perth, UK
- 2Department of Orthopaedics, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK
- Correspondence to James GB Maclean, Perth Royal Infirmary, Department of Orthopaedics, Jeanfield Road, Perth PH1 1QJ, UK;
Contributors Contact with spinal injury units and provision of numbers undertaken by the first author. Analysis including statistics and write up and literature review undertaken by both authors.
- Received 10 May 2011
- Accepted 20 October 2011
- Published Online First 14 December 2011
Objectives To obtain data regarding admissions of U19 rugby players to spinal injury units in Great Britain and Ireland and to compare this with a recent peak in presentation in Scotland. To assess the current state of data collection and subsequent analysis of serious neck injuries. To analyse the mechanism of injury in this group of at-risk players.
Design Retrospective case series.
Participants Spinal injury units in Great Britain and Ireland.
Outcome measures Annual frequency of serious neck injuries. Analysis of injury types, neurological deficit and mechanism of injury.
Results 36 Injuries were recorded. 10 Of these occurred in Scotland since 1996 of which six have occurred in the past 4 years. This compared with 14 in Ireland over the same period. 12 Cases were traced in England and Wales since 2000; records were not available before this date. No prospective collation of data is performed by the home unions and inconsistency of data collection exists. The mean age was 16.2 years. 16 Of the 36 admissions had complete neurological loss, 9 had incomplete neurological injury and 11 had cervical column injury without spinal cord damage. The mechanism of injury was tackle in 17 (47%), scrum in 13 (36%), two each due to the maul and collision, and one each due to a kick and a ruck. Some degree of spinal cord injury occurred in 92% of scrum injuries (61% complete) and 53% of tackle injuries (29% complete).
Conclusion U19 rugby players continue to sustain serious neck injuries necessitating admission to spinal injury units with a low but persistent frequency. The recent rate of admission in Scotland is disproportionately high when the respective estimated playing populations are considered. While more injuries were sustained in the tackle, spinal cord injury was significantly more common in neck injury sustained in the scrum (p<0.001). No register of catastrophic neck injuries exists despite repeated calls over the past three decades, and a study such as this has not been reported before. Data collection of this serious category of injury is incomplete and very variable across the home unions, as a consequence a large proportion of the serious neck injuries that have occurred in U19 players over the past 14 years have not been analysed. Rigorous data collection and analysis have to be established so that problem areas of the game such as scrum engagement and the tackle can be made safer.
Competing interests None.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed